Essay about Free Will and Determinism Views - 1610 Words

The aim of this essay is to prove the reliability of and why Libertarianism is the most coherent of the three Free Will and Determinism views. It refers to the idea of human free will being true, that one is not determined, and therefore, they are morally responsible. In response to the quote on the essay, I am disagreeing with Wolf. This essay will be further strengthened with the help of such authors as C.A. Campell, R. Taylor and R.M. Chisholm. They present similar arguments, which essentially demonstrate that one could have done otherwise and one is the sole author of the volition. I will present the three most common arguments in support of Libertarianism, present an objection against Libertarianism and attempt to rebut it as well as†¦show more content†¦In addition Campbell clarifies that for this to be accurate: predictability and unintelligibility of an act must be also true. These mean that no one could have done the choosing for them and that the act cannot be expl ained, respectively. However, if it does not follow one’s character, how is it a random act (also known as agent causality)? Likewise, one must be able to predict the behaviour of someone they know well. Even so, in the end it is all about probability, just like trying to predict weather. One cannot answer why, so it must be random because if one shows it necessarily had to happen, they are giving it a cause. So, all in all, why should one limit themselves to the outer person when there is an inner experience? There are actual meanings to acts and others will not know them. As a result one does have free will. Taylor’s view on Libertarianism is very similar. He believes that one has inner acts and that they are the sole creator of the act (so, they could have done otherwise). He says that it is the only thing that makes sense. It is a denial of any antecedent acts, character and the similar. Furthermore, he says that all actions are caused, but unlike in determinism, they are all triggered by the sole author themselves. A sole author in this case is a human, one that is capable of being the first to cause a chain. The sole author can initiate an action through itsShow MoreRelatedThe View That Determinism Is Not Incompatible With Free Will3559 Words   |  15 Pages11/01/2014 Compatibilism: Discussion and concerns Compatibilism is defined as â€Å"the view that determinism is not incompatible with free will.† In this holding, if determinism were valid, a person still has free will. One of the initial forms of compatibilism is the holding that to be imbued with free will â€Å"is simply for one’s choice to cause one’s actions. Free will is basically doing what one wants; in the example of Hume, free will is basically defined as â€Å"a power of acting or not acting, according toRead MoreComparing Compatibilism Vs Incompatibilism : A Compatibilist View1332 Words   |  6 PagesIncompatibilism: a compatibilist view Does determinism imply that there is no free will, as the incompatibilists argue, or does it allow for free will, as the compatibilists argue? Determinism is the doctrine, that every event, as well as human actions is determined by causes that are independent to the will. From determinism, two opposing views were identified. The incompatibilists view that determinism implies no free will, or the compatibilists view that determinism still allows for free will. The incompatibilistRead MoreEssay on Choice and Free Will1511 Words   |  7 Pagesâ€Å"Free will† is the power of acting without the constraint of necessity or fate. Free will has long been debated by scholars, philosophers, and psychologists. It is a subject that has been argued, theorized, and predicted to the extent of human ability, but recent data has been brought up by two psychologists named Shirley Matile Ogletree and Crystal D. Oberle. These two psychologists assess surveys given to college level students to evaluate the â€Å"common† or â€Å"plain† perspective of free will. TheyRead MoreAnalysis Of The Philosophical Concepts Of Determinism And Free Will1711 Words   |  7 PagesAnalysis of Free Will The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy defines â€Å"free will† as the discretion to choose between varieties of courses of action.The debate and arguments that surround free will have occupied philosophers for many centuries. Many scholars believe that the concept of free will is connected to the concept of responsibility, guilt, sin and other judgments that apply to the actions that are freely chosen by people. Other philosophers also link free will to the concept of persuasionRead MoreFilm Analysis of Minority Report Essay968 Words   |  4 Pagesâ€Å"According to the traditional view of man, what distinguishes him from animals is his freedom to choose between one course of action and another, his freedom to seek good and avoid evil. The animal has no freedom, but is determined by physical and biological laws; like a machine, the animal responds whenever the appropriate stimulus is present† (Bolles 1963, p.182). In Minority Report (2002) one of the main issues i s free will versus determinism. Is there some point that people can and do changeRead MoreDeterminism, Hard And Soft887 Words   |  4 Pages Determinism: According to Sappington (1990) there are two types of determinism, hard and soft. He states that those who hold hard determinism say that human behavior is completely determined by outside factors and that ideas such a free will or moral responsibility are meaningless. Many famous psychologists take this approach such as Freud who believed that people’s behavior is controlled by unconscious factors and any conscious reasons given are simply the brain rationalizing actions to the superegoRead MoreDeterminism And Free Will Essay1518 Words   |  7 PagesDeterminism and Free Will When the topic of metaphysics is mentioned, focus shifts to philosophical perspectives that give an explanation of the fundamental nature of being or existence and the universe that encompasses both. Metaphysics often seeks to answer basic questions, such as what is there and what is it like. One of the key branches of metaphysics is ontology, which refers to the philosophical study of the nature of existence, being, reality, or becoming. The significant ontologicalRead MoreJohn Chaffee s Philosophy Textbook1203 Words   |  5 PagesIn the beginning of chapter four of John Chaffee’s philosophy textbook we are confronted with a question, â€Å"are you free?† (Chaffee 2013 p.171). Although a majority of people would answer â€Å"yes, of course† to a question like this that seems cut and dry but in philosophy, we have to be willing to look deeper into the question being asked. Dive in with an open mind and ask yourself whether or not the choices you make in yo ur life are truly yours or are they governed by outside forces out of your controlRead MoreFree Will and Libertanianism View1101 Words   |  4 PagesWhether or not humans have free will is a very popular question. This is because everyone wants to know if the decisions they make are truly theirs or if their decisions matter at all. If everything is predetermined then what you choose wouldn’t matter because it would be bound to happen regardless of if you chose it or not. Without free will many people believe that life would have less meaning to it. With free will comes power and importance. Having the ability to choose what will happen givesRead More Existentialism Vs. Determinism Essay783 Words   |  4 Pages Free Will nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Analyzing our individual free will can be very intriguing and can almost reach the point of being paradoxical. Ultimately, free will determines the level of responsibility we claim for our actions. Obviously, if outside forces determine our choices, we cannot be held responsible for our actions. However, if our choices are made with total freedom than certainly we must claim responsibility for our